HPE, HP Sued for Elbowing Out Older Employees


Hewlett Packard Enterprise and HP are facing a potential class action lawsuit brought earlier this month by four former employees.

The companies engaged in widespread age discrimination during a restructuring of the legacy computer and printer manufacturer, according to their complaint, filed in U.S. District Court in San Jose, California.

HP from 2012 to 2015 made a series of discriminatory job cuts involving tens of thousands of workers, the suit alleges. Cuts made late last year, when the company split into two separate units, reflected a well-publicized effort to become "younger," according to the complaint.

HPE CEO Meg Whitman (who was then CEO of the undivided HP) in 2013 told a group of securities analysts that the company needed to transform itself from a "labor diamond" into a "labor pyramid" or a "quite flat triangle" with young employees at its base, according to the complaint.

The plaintiffs are seeking to have the suit confirmed as a class action case for former HP and HPE employees who were 40 years old or older when they were cut -- a class that potentially could number in the thousands.

The four plaintiffs are Donna Forsythe, who was laid off from HPE in May at age 62; Arun Vatturi, who lost his HP job in January at age 52; Dan Weiland, who was cut from HP in July 2015 at age 63; and Sydney Staton, who was cut in April 2015 at age 54.

HP and HPE officials denied the allegations and said their companies were committed to lawful employment practices.

"HP has long been committed to the principles of equal opportunity, diversity and inclusion," said spokesperson Tom Suiter.

"Any decision to implement a workforce reduction is always difficult, but we take care to make tough decisions based on legitimate, nondiscriminatory reasons," he added. "We are aware of the claims, deny them and plan to defend against them."

"Hewlett Packard Enterprise has a longstanding commitment to the principles of equal employment opportunity and age inclusion is no exception," said spokesperson Blair Hinderliter. "The decision to implement a workforce reduction is always difficult, but we are confident that our decisions were based on legitimate decisions unrelated to age."

The employment practices of Silicon Valley firms have been a subject of scrutiny for some time. The tech industry has developed a reputation not only of lacking racial and gender diversity, but also of blatantly favoring younger employees.

"This has been a problem that was well documented at Google and other software companies," observed Kevin Krewell, principal analyst at Tirias Research.

"The rationale is that young people are more willing to work long hours and sacrifice work/life balance to deliver a product," he told the E-Commerce Times.

The problem of age discrimination at Silicon Valley companies is compounded by the fact that industry leaders largely have been unapologetic about the practice, Laurie McCann, senior attorney at AARP Foundation Litigation, said this spring in testimony before the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission.

HP's goal apparently was keep salaries down at the company, but the way it was executed may have crossed a line into discriminatory behavior, said Rob Enderle, principal analyst at the Enderle Group.

"Whitman has seemed excessively focused on salaries of late," he told the E-Commerce Times.

"The nature of her compensation is that she makes more as expenses drop, showcasing a natural affinity for her own income over that of others," Enderle said. "The intent wasn't to discriminate by age, but that appears to be the result."

David Jones is a freelance writer based in Essex County, New Jersey. He has written for Reuters, Bloomberg, Crain's New York Business and The New York Times.

0 Comment

Leave a Reply

Captcha image


  • 5300c769af79e

    Google is Testing an App Download Queue Feature for Google Play

    According to screenshots posted online from Android Police, at least one person is seeing a new beta feature from Google Play.The feature in testing is aimed specifically at those who download apps while on the go, something many of us probably do.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Apple Logic Pro X (for Mac)

    For post-production, film and video game composers, and home-studio musicians alike, Logic Pro X ($199.Compare Similar ProductsCompare Avid Pro Tools 11 %displayPrice% Steinberg Cubase 7 %displayPrice% MOTU Digital Performer 8 (for Mac) %displayPrice% Cakewalk SONAR X3 Producer %displayPrice% Apple GarageBand 10 (for Mac) %displayPrice% Setup, Installation, and User Interface To get started with Logic Pro X 10.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Google Introduces Messaging App Allo, New Video Chat App Duo

    In an announcement no one saw coming today at Google I/O, Google went ahead and unveiled two new apps, one for messaging and another for video chatting.It learns if you are a “haha” or “lol” person, can suggest responses based off of photos being shared (yep, it does photos too), and brings the power of the new Google Assistant.
  • 5300c769af79e

    UK 'Snooper's Charter' Surveillance Bill Becomes Law

    A controversial UK surveillance bill has become law, despite efforts to stop it.The Investigatory Powers Act 2016 today received the final stamp of approval from the Queen—a practice called Royal Assent.