Airbnb Fights City Hall Over San Francisco Registration Rule


Airbnb recently filed suit against San Francisco over a new rule governing short-term rentals, which the city's Board of Supervisors approved last month.

An Airbnb-supported law adopted earlier this year requires short-term rental hosts to register with the city, but it's estimated that only about 20 percent of them -- about 1,400 out of 7,000 -- have done so.

The new rule requires short-term rental listing services like Airbnb to enforce the law by ensuring that hosts advertising on their websites have registered with the city before posting ads online.

When the city flags suspect rental ads, the listing service must respond with details about those properties within one business day -- or incur fines of up to $1,000 a day per listing, as well as face misdemeanor charges.

Airbnb had vowed to fight the rule, and late last month filed suit in United States District Court.

"We believe we are on firm legal footing with this case because this is a piece of common sense legislation that is supported by landlords, tenants, hotels and hotel workers," said San Francisco Supervisor Aaron Peskin.

"We are confident that our city attorney will successfully present our case," he told the E-Commerce Times.

The registration system for short-term rental properties -- which Airbnb had supported -- isn't working, notes the company's complaint.

However, the rule requiring listing companies to enforce registration violates the 1996 Communications Decency Act, it argues.

Congress passed the CDA, Title V of the Telecommunications Act of 1996, with the goal of regulating pornographic material on the Internet. However, the U.S. Supreme Court in 1997 struck down its anti-decency provisions in Reno v. ACLU.

Airbnb's case is based on Section 230 of the Act, which gives immunity from liability to providers and users of an interactive computer service that publishes information provided by others.

There's a dearth of rental apartments in San Francisco, which has sent rents skyrocketing and seen landlords engage in a variety of shenanigans.

For example, one landlord of a North Beach apartment recently raised a tenant's rent from US$1,800 a month to $8,000.

In another caes, landlords reportedly are seeking to evict a tenant for using the appliances in her unit.

Instances like these concerned the Board of Supervisors enough that they unanimously passed the rule requiring short-term hosts to include their license numbers when advertising online.

Introduced by Supervisor David Campos, a long-time opponent of Airbnb, the rule also attracted the support of Supervisor Aaron Peskin, who has fought for affordable housing in San Francisco for years.

"The problem is not the city's motivations but the fact that its method for achieving those goals contravenes Section 230," said Gautam S. Hans, director of the Center for Democracy & Technology's San Francisco's office.

"The courts wouldn't look at the effect on the housing market or anything else when interpreting the [Section] 230 claims," he told the E-Commerce Times. "Airbnb has a strong case given the statute and existing case law."

Further, liability "cannot be based on the presence or absence of a registration number or whether the user can legally offer the service," noted David Greene, civil liberties director at the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

The requirement of specific content -- the registration numbers of advertisers -- "is a restriction based on speech," he told the E-Commerce Times, "implicating the first amendment."

Richard Adhikari has written about high-tech for leading industry publications since the 1990s and wonders where it's all leading to. Will implanted RFID chips in humans be the Mark of the Beast? Will nanotech solve our coming food crisis? Does Sturgeon's Law still hold true? You can connect with Richard on Google+.

0 Comment

Leave a Reply

Captcha image


  • 5300c769af79e

    Analytics, IoT Crucial To Mobile E-Commerce Growth

    But analytics, IoT, and other tools have help make sense of that data, according a report from Frost & Sullivan.Since the advent of popular mobile payment services, such as Apple Pay and Android Pay, the mobile e-commerce market has become worth billions of dollars annually and continues to grow.
  • 5300c769af79e

    What I'd Like to See From HTC in 2017

    You can probably ask most people in the Android community and they’d say HTC has their work cut out for them in 2017.Until all headphones are shipped as USB Type-C or are completely Bluetooth, just keep the headphone jack.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Despite Intense Scrutiny, Uber Lays Another Egg

    The company's "greyballing" technology is designed to hide the standard city app view in specific cases -- for example, from former riders blocked for being abusive, or to prevent fraud.However, some drivers have used it to circumvent local regulators, a practice that Uber no longer will allow, according to Chief Security Officer Joe Sullivan.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Google Fiber Plots Wireless Service Despite Rollout Delays

    A new report finds that Google Fiber is being hampered by a slow and costly rollout of its physical high-speed internet service.To overcome delays and cost overruns, the company is reportedly looking at wireless alternatives.