Zuckerberg Aims to Smooth Conservatives' Ruffled Feathers

...


ManageEngine OpManager, a powerful NMS for monitoring your network, physical & virtual (VMware/ HyperV) servers & other IT devices. Deploy and start monitoring in less than an hour. Trusted by over a million admins world-wide. Try it for free.

Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg invited a group of 15 media executives and right-leaning pundits, including talk show host Glenn Beck, to meet with him Wednesday to discuss accusations that the social media network biased it's trending news topics to omit conservative viewpoints.

In addition to Beck, founder of the multiplatform conservative network The Blaze, Zuckerberg extended invitations to Arthur Brooks, president of the American Enterprise Institute; Dana Perino, Fox News co-host and former George W. Bush press secretary; Barry Bennett, senior advisor to Donald Trump and former Ben Carson campaign manager; and Zack Moffatt, cofounder of Targeted Victory and former digital director for the 2012 Mitt Romney campaign.

Brooks planned to approach the meeting with an open mind, he noted in a Facebook post -- but he also referenced a study that claimed 84 percent of Americans considered the national press biased.

"Innovative new companies have a massive opening to change this by disrupting old patterns, empowering citizens to bypass gatekeepers and helping build a newly diverse marketplace of ideas," he wrote. "But to do this, it is vital that new media avoid making old mistakes."

The uproar began last week after a Gizmodo report alleged that Facebook regularly deemphasized conservative viewpoints in its trending news topics section.

The main source of the story was a former journalist on the project, according to the report.

However, several former news curators also provided input, claiming they were told to inject certain stories into the trending topics feed even if they weren't trending, and to leave out news about Facebook, Gizmodo reported.

Facebook responded to the controversy with a lengthy defense of its curation process and a personal response from Zuckerberg.

The company was launching a full investigation into the allegations, he said -- yet in the next sentence claimed there was no evidence to support any accounts of suppression.

"To serve our diverse community we are committed to building a platform for all ideas," Zuckerberg wrote.

The company had rigorous guidelines that did not permit the prioritization of one viewpoint over another or the suppression of political perspectives, he maintained.

Trending Topics launched in 2014. The topics that initially appear are surfaced by an algorithm that identifies items that have a high degree of mentions. The algorithm also utilizes an RSS website crawler that identifies breaking news, explained Justin Osofsky, vice president of operations at Facebook, in a post published several days after the Gizmodo story broke.

The Trending Topics team reviews the items and corroborates the reporting by making sure three major outlets are covering the story, Osofsky said, and applies a category to the story. The Trending Topics items are personalized to individual users based on an algorithm that includes what the individual Facebook user has liked before, the geographic location of a user, feedback from the user about previous trending topics, and other data.

The allegations raised in the Gizmodo report are "troubling," noted Facebook Vice President of Global Policy Joel Kaplan, a former senior aide in the Bush White House, in a lengthy response to the controversy last week.

An equal number of conservatives and progressives use the Facebook platform, he said.

"This matters to us because Facebook has always been a place where anyone can share their opinions and engage in discussion," wrote Kaplan.

Independent Journal - America has more than 7.5 million fans on Facebook and has leveraged the network to grow its media business, he pointed out, and Glenn Beck has more than 3.2 million Facebook fans.

There is not a lot of evidence to back up the Gizmodo story's anonymous source allegations that Facebook suppressed conservative ideas, observed Rick Edmonds, media business analyst at the Poynter Institute.

Still, "right or wrong, the Gizmodo expose highlighted that human judgment goes into the trending recommendations," he told the E-Commerce Times, "and that's also true -- in my view -- if the humans are simply writing the rules for the algorithm."

David Jones is a freelance writer based in Essex County, New Jersey. He has written for Reuters, Bloomberg, Crain's New York Business and The New York Times.

Categories
Guide
0 Comment

Leave a Reply

Captcha image


RELATED BY

  • 5300c769af79e

    Rapid Tech Change Challenges IT Leaders

    Agility is the name of the game for today's IT organizations, but keeping up with the rapid pace of change is difficult.Gone are the days when IT procured and managed all of an organization's technology.
  • 5300c769af79e

    10 IT Hiring Plans For Second Half Of 2016

    Here's a closer look at CIO hiring plans for the remaining months of 2016, including layoffs, the most in-demand IT skills, and the hottest regions.As we enter the second half of 2016, CIOs surveyed say they expect to slightly curtail hiring plans compared to the first half of the year and the same time a year ago, according to the recently released results of an IT hiring forecast report by recruiting firm Robert Half Technology.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Apple May Open Up Siri, Make Echo-Like Speaker

    Similar to the Echo, Apple's home speaker will be able to turn on music playlists, set timers and alarms, and read back the news.A source with direct knowledge of Apple's plans told the publication the device will also be able to interact with Apple's Homekit platform, allowing it to turn appliances on or off via voice commands.
  • 5300c769af79e

    #TBT: We Wrongly Thought Neptune Pine Would be Awesome

    Please tell me you remember the Neptune Pine.Back in late 2014, the Neptune Pine finally launched, about a year after its debut on Kickstarter.