EFF Sues Feds Over 'Unconstitutional' Copyright Law


The Electronic Frontier Foundation this week sued the government on behalf of technology creators and researchers in a bid to overturn parts of US copyright law it deems unconstitutional.

Two provisions in Section 1201 of the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) restrict user access to purchased content, which violates the First Amendment, according to the EFF.

Section 1201 prohibits people from circumventing software that restricts access to legally purchased materials like films, songs, and the computer code controlling vehicles, devices, and applications.

"The First Amendment preserves our right to transform creative works to express a new message, and to research and talk about the computer code that controls so much of our world," EFF staff attorney Kit Walsh said in a statement. "Section 1201 threatens ordinary people with financial ruin or even a prison sentence for exercising those freedoms, and that cannot stand."

The maximum penalty for violating DMCA laws is a $500,000 fine or five-year jail sentence, according to BBC News.

The EFF represents Johns Hopkins University computer security researcher Matthew Green, as well as computer scientist and inventor Andrew "bunnie" Huang and his company Alphamax LLC.

"Whereas we once readily expressed feelings and new ideas through remixes and hardware modifications, now we must first pause and ask: does this violate Section 1201?" Huang wrote in a blog post.

"I am but one instrument in a large orchestra performing the symphony for freedom," he continued. "But I hope my small part can remind us that once upon a time, there was a world free of such artificial barriers, and that creativity and expression go hand-in-hand with the ability to share without fear."

Introduced in 1998, the DMCA was created to address copyright for media in the digital age. But Section 1201, designed to stop people ripping DVDs and sharing the content online, has residual effects. As BBC News points out, it stops people from modifying a DVD player to play discs from different regions or deconstructing a medical device's software to search for vulnerabilities.

"If future generations are going to be able to understand and control their own machines, and to participate fully in making rather than simply consuming culture, Section 1201 has to go," Walsh said.

The EFF has been fighting this battle for several years, and has been among those pushing for Congress to revamp the DMCA.

0 Comment

Leave a Reply

Captcha image


  • 5300c769af79e

    HTC U Ultra Review

    When HTC showed up in January with the HTC U Ultra, we were skeptical about the entire schtick.We’ve had one in house for a little over a week and have a whole bunch to say about it in this lengthy HTC U Ultra review.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Google Home Will Drop to $99 This Week for a Limited Time ($30 Off)

    Here’s a pro tip: don’t buy Google Home until Wednesday, November 23.On that day, Google will discount the smart home assistant to $99, down from its original retail price of $129.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Top 10 Highest Paying Tech Companies

    Here's a cheat sheet based on Glassdoor's list of the highest paying US tech companies in 2016.Six-figure salaries are the norm when it comes to the top 10 tech companies that offer the highest pay in 2016, according to a recent survey from jobs and recruiting site Glassdoor.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Federal Agencies Mirror Commercial Websites for Encryption

    gov) domains and their subdomains," GSA said in a notice published earlier this year.In terms of creating new federal websites, as executive branch domains become registered, the dot-gov program will submit them to Web browsers for preloading, GSA said.