Google Defends Android in European Antitrust Case


The Android mobile operating system helped usher in the era of cheap smartphones and gives consumers greater choice over apps than Apple's iOS, Google argued today in a response to an antitrust complaint from European regulators.

Google insisted its practice of pre-installing its own suite of apps on Android smartphones and tablets is easily reversible by end users and doesn't prevent device manufacturers from pre-installing their own rival apps.

The filing was an official answer to a European Commission investigation into anti-competitive Android practices opened last April. The Commission is focusing on three potentially illegal practices: Google's requirement that manufacturers exclusively pre-install its own apps; preventing developers from installing "Android forks"; and bundling of certain services to hinder rivals.

"The response we filed today shows how the Android ecosystem carefully balances the interests of users, developers, hardware makers, and mobile network operators," Google explained. "Android hasn't hurt competition, it's expanded it."

Google also argued that its measures to prevent forks—versions of Android that device manufacturers heavily modify—do not violate antitrust laws. Forks are discouraged to prevent the kind of fragmentation that would dilute the Android experience and render it less competitive with iOS, Google explained.

Even though Google prefers that its partners offer a pure Android experience, they are not required to do so. Android's Open Source Platform (AOSP) offers manufacturers the ability to customize the OS nearly any way they see fit. Devices based on that platform include Nokia's X line, introduced in 2013. The OS on those phones resembled Windows Phone devices, and they did not ship with Google's Play store for downloading apps.

But it's basically an all-or-nothing proposition. Either you go with AOSP and launch with no Google services, or choose Google and bundle all the apps its requires. You can't mix and match for a phone with Google Maps but Yahoo search pre-installed, for example.

Despite Google's assurances, the European Commission has traditionally taken a tough stance on antitrust issues in the tech industry, including a landmark ruling against Microsoft in 2007. Google's response this week is the latest official filing in what could be a drawn out investigation with parallels to the Microsoft case. If Google loses, it could face a penalty of $7.5 billion, or 10 percent of its annual revenue, although the New York Times notes that Europe has levied much smaller penalties in previous cases.

0 Comment

Leave a Reply

Captcha image


  • 5300c769af79e

    Gmail Will Now Support Emails With Responsive Design

    Starting this month, Gmail will begin supporting emails made with responsive design.That means if an email has been created to automatically format differently depending on the screen size (the basic idea of responsive design), Gmail will allow that magic to happen.
  • 5300c769af79e

    LG Just Created a Button-Less Fingerprint Sensor That Hides Under a Display

    ” Schiller was referencing the company’s trashcan-shaped Mac Pro computer, but we are using it in reference to LG’s new fingerprint sensor that lives underneath a phone’s display and can be read without the need for a dedicated button.Yes, your mind is wandering into the proper place – LG’s new fingerprint reader will hide just below the glass on your next phone’s display, potentially leading to even cleaner, buttonless smartphone designs.
  • 5300c769af79e

    Password Manager LastPass Patches 2 Major Bugs

    Marketing manager Amber Gott pointed to a pair of unrelated bugs that left the LastPass Firefox browser extension open to attack.On Tuesday, Google Security Team researcher Tavis Ormandy reported a message-hijacking bug targeting the LastPass Firefox add-on.
  • 5300c769af79e

    iOS 10: Siri Integrates With Third-Party Apps

    Whether your organization is considering the use of big data and analytics, or has taken its first As Apple gears up for its iOS 10 public beta in July, a select group of developers will now be able to sync up their apps with users' Siri demands.The software development kit (SDK) can also be used by automakers who want to let Siri control Apple's CarPlay apps.