Appeals Court Blocks FCC's Public Broadband Expansion Plans


Join us on September 8th for a webinar where Lockheed Martin cybersecurity experts will share prac

This week, a US appeals court ruled the FCC overstepped its bounds by trying to override state laws that prevent the creation of municipal broadband services. The FCC claimed these new services would provide jobs, as well as better service for businesses and individuals.

The US 6th Circuit Court of Appeals has struck down a Federal Communications Commission order concerning municipal broadband expansion, ruling that the FCC overstepped its authority by overriding state laws limiting municipal expansion.

The FCC, which passed the order in 2015 by a 3-2 vote, had relied on Section 706 of the Telecommunications Act of 1996 for the authority to preempt state laws to speed broadband deployment, but the court found the statue "falls short" in providing the FCC with sufficient authority.

The court also noted there are no statutes or FCC regulations requiring "municipalities to expand or otherwise to act in contravention of the preempted state statutory provisions."

The Aug. 10 decision (PDF) is a setback for FCC Chairman Tom Wheeler and for the commission's plans to encourage local broadband projects, and a victory for commercial broadband providers.

"While we continue to review the decision, it appears to halt the promise of jobs, investment and opportunity that community broadband has provided in Tennessee and North Carolina," Wheeler wrote in a statement. "In the end, I believe the Commission's decision to champion municipal efforts highlighted the benefits of competition and the need of communities to take their broadband futures in their own hands."

The appeals court cited a Tennessee law enacted in 1999 that said any municipality operating an electric plant is authorized to offer cable services, video services, and internet services -- but that authority is limited to "within its service area."

That law limits, for instance, EPB of Chattanooga, one of America's largest publicly owned electric power providers, from providing internet and cable service beyond its electrical system's footprint.

"In the past 18 months, over 50 communities have taken steps to build their own bridges across the digital divide," Wheeler continued. "The efforts of communities wanting better broadband should not be thwarted by the political power of those who, by protecting their monopoly, have failed to deliver acceptable service at an acceptable price."

The National Association of Regulatory Utility Commissioners (NARUC), which opposed the FCC action, released a statement applauding the court's decision, calling the FCC's actions an offense to the US Constitution.

"The law is clear. The Court recognized the simple fact that nothing in the Telecommunications Act provides the FCC with the power to give authority to a state entity that is not granted by that state's constitution or legislature," NARUC committee on telecommunications chair Chris Nelson wrote.

[Read more about the FCC's plans for 5G networks.]

Republican FCC commissioner Ajit Pai also wrote in his support of the ruling that the court's decision was "a big victory for the rule of law and federalism" and urged the FCC to focus on deregulation.

"Rather than wasting its time on illegal efforts to intrude on the prerogatives of state governments, the FCC should focus on implementing a broadband deployment agenda to eliminate regulatory barriers that discourage those in the private sector from deploying and upgrading next-generation networks," he wrote.

USTelecom president Walter McCormick added his opinion as well, noting that FCC's authority does not extend to preemption of state legislatures' decisions.

"As an industry that shares the commission's interest in accelerating broadband deployment, we would suggest that the best way for the FCC to accomplish its goals is to concentrate on eliminating federal regulatory impediments to innovation and investment -- where there remains to be much that can and should be done," McCormick wrote.

0 Comment

Leave a Reply

Captcha image


  • 5300c769af79e

    Yahoo Expands Board to Appease Contentious Investor

    As part of the agreement, Starboard has withdrawn its slate of nominees to the Yahoo board.The board and management "remain focused and dedicated to the exploration of strategic alternatives" and the "execution of strategy for the operating business," Yahoo spokesperson Rebecca Neufeld told the E-Commerce Times.
  • 5300c769af79e

    The Social Takeover: The Top 5 Social Media Threats

    Download The face of cyber security is shifting.With the advent of social media, the adversary has found a new vehicle for tried and true threats as well as a whole�new breed of potential attacks, many of which are only beginning to take full form.
  • 5300c769af79e

    iPhone 7 Rumors: Improved Camera, Quadraphonic Speakers

    To help you optimize security as you cope with complexity, InformationWeek is offering you an excl The iPhone 7 rumor mill continues to churn out photos and information indicating a redesigned rear case and improved camera specs.The photos also show three memory chips placed next to the camera, including a 256GB chip, which would be a first for the iPhone.
  • 5300c769af79e

    The 4 Fundamental Attributes of Customer Loyalty, Part 3

    This is the second in a four-part series on modern approaches to improving customer loyalty through customer engagement.The third of four attributes of customer loyalty programs is contextual interaction, and it might not be obvious because it can mean different things depending on the circumstances.